skip to main content skip to footer


My opinion HIDDEN GEM of the area ... read more
Brad Ryan via - Jan 18, 2022
The place was kinda busy due to the lunch rush, but worth the wait. I ordered the meatball sub, my wife had the turkey and we split a cinnamon roll that was roughly the size of my face. The food is great for what you pay, and the staff is helpful and friendly. Definitely recommend.
Micah Harrison via - Dec 24, 2021
Service was nice, subs where good and at a reasonable price ... read more
Trent Anderson via - Dec 16, 2021
I took my little boy here for the first time and told him how great the pizza was, thank you so much for not letting me down. The staff was really great we were well treated and now my little boy says he wants to live close to Papa Kelsey's so he can go there every other day!
Jeffery Olson via - Dec 2, 2021
Muy ricos los hot subs.
david beltran via - Nov 18, 2021
They tried to give our sandwich away but it was very good.
Debbye McAtee via - Sep 26, 2021
Kristen Binkley via - Sep 3, 2021
Gluten free pizza was small but delicious! Also, it was pretty pricey but because it tasted good I would get it again! I grew up with the owner, Patricia Kay and was sad that she was not there so I could say hello but I absolutely would eat there again! The cashier was friendly and attentive to my Celiac/gluten free needs. Celiac fri ... read more
T A via - Aug 10, 2021
Papa Kelsey's is our favorite place in town to eat. Everything is good. Service is always great.
Kevin Orton via - Aug 9, 2021
Great pizza! The chicken bacon ranch was delicious and they put the pepperonis under the cheese. Which is good for deceiving the children. The order was done on time and location was central and easy to get to.
Wade Brinton via - Aug 5, 2021
Good subs!
Danielle Lindsey via - Jul 25, 2021
Good variety of subs and they're all good ... read more
Jareth Hansen via - Jul 13, 2021
Staff was helpful and very nice. Pizza was decent for the price and did the job feeding us dinner.
Kristen Bohm via - Jul 11, 2021
They have great pizzas and subs. I always have to stop by everytime I go to Burley Id.
Terry via - Jul 10, 2021
Good food good company. Always a good combination.
Jennie VanZant via - Jul 7, 2021
Been driving by this place for awhile and decided to stop in for a Hot Sub (Meatball). Delish! Cant wait to try another! 😀 ... read more
Cyrus Pintor via - Jun 30, 2021
I absolutely love this place ❤ best sandwiches ever. Tried the Chicken Malibu, it did NOT disappoint. The Grilled Chicken Caesar salad was bomb 💣. I will recommend this place to family and friends.
Sylvia Lujan via - Jun 26, 2021
I love going to eat here!! Everyone is friendly and they bring our food out to us in the dining room. My new favorite is the chicken fried sub!
Guylia James via - Jun 24, 2021
Good food ... read more
Parker Prien via - Jun 24, 2021
Enjoyed those subs and the ceaser salad ... read more
Steve Misemer via - Jun 7, 2021
Never disappoints. Reasonably quick, great atmosphere, excellent food. What more can I say? ... read more
Zachary Hunsaker via - May 28, 2021
Best hot subs, all good food ... read more
Sean Michael O'Donahue via - May 8, 2021
Always great service and great food!
Danielle Jones via - May 6, 2021
Their steak sandwich was tender and full of flavor. Will go back there again.
Donald Smith via - May 1, 2021
This is a tried and true establishment in Burley. Their lunch specials are great and I just LOVE their fresh daily cinnamon rolls, that is when I am fortunate enough to beat the rush for the ONE pan they make daily. This place is reliable, that is, you always know what you will get.
Idaho_B&T via - Apr 22, 2021
Very clean. Very awesome people ... read more
Fay Jamison via - Apr 20, 2021
There food is sooooo good love eating here and will continue ... read more
ShayLynn Blass via - Mar 31, 2021
Great sandwiches ... read more
Brock Van Tassell via - Feb 14, 2021
That was the best pizza and best crust I've ever had. Thanks so much!
Ken Barnes via - Feb 4, 2021
Hometown Favorite
I have had several items at this shop over the years and they were delicious (salads, sandwiches, and pizza). I am partial to the Pizza Sub (with peppers and olives added). I typically did take out, but the shop has a cozy atmosphere for dine-in...eating. Great family owned business.More ... read more
Bkirkpat25 via - Jan 15, 2021
Best sandwich I have ever eaten. Nice friendly people serving you your food. And a great atmosphere. A must stop if you are in the Burley area.
Roger Galow via - Jan 14, 2021
Way good always an excellent stop when traveling through ... read more
Henry Dahl via - Jan 5, 2021
The chili verde sandwich is really good. Not just really but really really good. —- Sandra Warren
The chili verde sandwich is really good. Not just really but really really good. —- Sandra Warren ... read more
Rachael Spaulding via - Jan 2, 2021
It was amazing! Fabulous food, wonderful staff!! Stopped in on our way from Boise to Pocatello. Pizza, sandwiches and salad were all delicious! Even got a homemade cinnamon roll. Best ever!
erika sutton via - Dec 29, 2020
Yummy yummy food 🍱 😋 must have
Yummy yummy food 🍱 😋 must have ... read more
Nadine R. Hellewell via - Dec 19, 2020
I love the bread ... read more
Troy Mortensen via - Dec 9, 2020
Great food as always!
Julie Bench via - Dec 9, 2020
Excellent pizza, reasonable price. Small building, keep an eye out for it. We were pulling a trailer so we needed to park on the side street.
Jim Rasmussen via - Oct 19, 2020
Really good service and fairly quick.
Bambi Lopez via - Sep 24, 2020
great sandwiches and customer service
great sandwiches and customer service ... read more
Jason Gudgell via - Aug 30, 2020
good asf I recommended whatever tbh
good asf I recommended whatever tbh ... read more
Lorenzo Jr Arteaga via - Aug 20, 2020
My son love there sandwiches I love the bread n cinnamon rolls.
Rosa Burns via - Aug 6, 2020
You ought to the Italian sub , really delicious. Never tried the cinnamon rolls yet but soon will .
You ought to the Italian sub , really delicious. Never tried the cinnamon rolls yet but soon will . I’ve heard there good .
Domingo Estrada via - Jul 23, 2020
Great pizza and subs that come with a beautifully crafted salad. I loved this place as a kid and 10 years later I still really enjoy it.
Joshua Fenstermaker via - Jul 15, 2020
Love this place. Great food and service. Great memories.
Dustin Cahoon via - Jul 9, 2020
Good food ... read more
Don Twyford via - Jul 8, 2020
Great food great help Thank you ... read more
Sharyn Carsner via - Jul 3, 2020
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire